Shop Your Way
Shop Online
Shop thousands of Ace products online and choose Benge's Hardware for convenient pickup or delivery.
More Than Hardware
Store Services
Screen repair, key cutting, paint matching, delivery and more—all from your local Benge's team.
Backup Power
Backup Power Buyer's Guide
Not sure which backup power solution is right for your home? Answer a few quick questions and build a plan based on your home and power needs.
Your Local Butler-Tarkington Hardware Store
Local Hardware. Neighborhood Service.
Benge's Hardware – Butler-Tarkington serves homeowners, contractors and local businesses throughout Butler-Tarkington and Midtown Indianapolis with the products, services and knowledgeable local help to keep projects moving.
A Hardware Store Built Around Your Neighborhood
Whether you're tackling a weekend project at your home on Boulevard Place, stocking up for a jobsite near Butler University, or running a business along Restaurant Row, Benge's Hardware – Butler-Tarkington makes it easy to get the supplies you need without turning a quick trip into an all-day project.
Our local team is here to help homeowners, DIYers, contractors and businesses throughout Butler-Tarkington and Midtown Indianapolis find the right products, solve problems and get back to the job.
Serving Butler-Tarkington and surrounding Indianapolis neighborhoods since August 8, 2025. Formerly known as Benge's Hardware – Midtown.
Project Supplies From Brands You Know
Our Butler-Tarkington hardware store carries products for projects inside and outside the home, including grills and smokers, snow blowers, paint and stains, outdoor power equipment, hardware, hand tools, power tools and project accessories.
You'll also find lawn care products, plumbing supplies, cleaning essentials, portable and whole-home generator options, and specialty products from local makers.
Hardware Store Services in Butler-Tarkington
Benge's Hardware – Butler-Tarkington offers convenient in-store services for homeowners, DIYers, contractors and local businesses throughout Butler-Tarkington and Midtown Indianapolis. From paint and keys to propane and project materials, our local team can help you get more done in one trip.
Paint Color Matching & Custom Paint Mixing
Bring us a color sample or choose a new shade for your project. Our Butler-Tarkington team can help with paint color matching and custom paint mixing for interior, exterior and everyday home improvement projects.
Window Screen Replacement & Repair
Torn or damaged window and door screens don't always need to be replaced completely. Bring your screen to our Butler-Tarkington store and let our team help with screen repair and replacement options.
Wire, Rope & Chain Cutting
Get the amount you actually need for your project. We cut wire, rope and chain for home repairs, outdoor projects, jobsite needs and other applications right here in the store.
Glass & Acrylic Sheet Cutting
Working on a window, frame, cabinet or custom project? Our Butler-Tarkington hardware team can help cut glass and acrylic sheets for a variety of home, repair and DIY applications.
Key Cutting, Duplication & Auto Key Fobs
Need an extra key or replacement? Visit Benge's Hardware – Butler-Tarkington for key cutting and duplication, along with auto key fob programming for supported vehicles.
Propane Tank Refill & Exchange
Keep the grill, patio heater or other propane-powered equipment ready to go. Our Butler-Tarkington location offers convenient propane tank refill and exchange services close to home.
Carpet Cleaning Machine Rental
Take on deeper carpet cleaning without buying specialized equipment. Carpet cleaning machine rentals are available through our Butler-Tarkington store for home and property-cleaning projects.
Not sure what your project requires? Stop by Benge's Hardware – Butler-Tarkington and talk with our local team. Whether you're maintaining a home, managing a property or getting materials together for the next job, we'll help you find the products and services you need to keep moving.
Butler-Tarkington Customers
Loved by Your Neighbors
See why local homeowners and professionals choose Benge's Hardware – Butler-Tarkington.
“He was incredibly knowledgeable and helpful and it made me feel like I wasn’t just a customer.”
“The only place I go to when im working on the house they'll have everything you need”
“Very large hardware with very helpful hardware men. It’s the most impressive hardware store around!”